Auth0, Clerk, FusionAuth, Kinde, PropelAuth, SuperTokens and WorkOS.
With a CLI: Auth0, Clerk, PropelAuth, SuperTokens and WorkOS.
Of the 9 auth providers we drove up to 15 Nov 2026, FusionAuth and SuperTokens work best for AI agents. With them, our agent got in, did nearly all the core work and could leave without a person. 8 of 9 let our agent in; sign-up stopped it at the other 1.
9 auth providers, driven 1 to 15 Nov 2026.
Best for an agent that must also leave cleanly
The browser sign-up asked for a name, an email and a password, with no CAPTCHA and no email check.
Best for an agent that needs a working app before anyone has an account
One documented API call returned a development app with its secret key: no form, no email.
Best for trying the API with no account at all
One documented call made an unclaimed test environment and returned its key.
Best for an agent that works from a CLI
Sign-up took an email code in the browser, with no CAPTCHA.
Based on 9 of the 246 products we drove, last driven 15 Nov 2026.
| # | Auth provider | Level | Find | Get in | Use | Pay | Leave | Core work | In after | Driven | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | FusionAuthRuns locally | L4 Runs on its own | On its own | On its own | On its own | Not reached | On its own | 7 of 7 | 9 min | 15 Nov | 7 of 7 core tasksIn after 9 minDriven 15 Nov |
| 2 | PropelAuthNo key needed | L1 Needs a person | On its own | Stopped | Not reached | Not reached | Not reached | Unknown | Unknown | 9 Nov | Unknown core tasksIn after unknownDriven 9 Nov |
| 3 | SuperTokensSign-up in a browser | L4 Runs on its own | On its own | On its own | On its own | Partly | On its own | 10 of 10 | 8 min | 3 Nov | 10 of 10 core tasksIn after 8 minDriven 3 Nov |
| 4 | ClerkTry first, claim later | L3 Does the work | On its own | On its own | On its own | Not reached | Partly | 6 of 6 | 1 min | 1 Nov | 6 of 6 core tasksIn after 1 minDriven 1 Nov |
| 5 | WorkOSTry first, claim later | L3 Does the work | On its own | On its own | On its own | Not reached | Partly | 9 of 10 | 1 min | 2 Nov | 9 of 10 core tasksIn after 1 minDriven 2 Nov |
| 6 | Auth0Sign-up in a browser | L3 Does the work | On its own | On its own | On its own | Stopped | Partly | 9 of 10 | 3 min | 2 Nov | 9 of 10 core tasksIn after 3 minDriven 2 Nov |
| 7 | KindeSign-up in a browser | L3 Does the work | On its own | On its own | On its own | Partly | Partly | 8 of 9 | 4 min | 3 Nov | 8 of 9 core tasksIn after 4 minDriven 3 Nov |
| 8 | HumanMirrorKey by API | L3 Does the work | Partly | On its own | Partly | On its own | Partly | 6 of 8 | 3 min | 15 Nov | 6 of 8 core tasksIn after 3 minDriven 15 Nov |
| 9 | Web3Auth (MetaMask Embedded Wallets)Sign-up in a browser | L3 Does the work | Partly | On its own | Partly | Partly | Partly | 4 of 7 | 25 min | 3 Nov | 4 of 7 core tasksIn after 25 minDriven 3 Nov |
9 auth providers, driven 1 to 15 Nov 2026.
AgentDrives StudyWhich auth provider works best for AI agents?
Got in on its own.
89%8 of 9
| What | Count | Out of |
|---|---|---|
| Got in on its own. | 8 | 9 |
AgentDrives drives, 1 Oct – 18 Nov 2026
Cite this figure
AgentDrives, "Got in on its own.", 18 Nov 2026. https://agentdrives.com/research/best-auth-providers-for-ai-agents#dc-1
No time measured: PropelAuth.
9 auth providers, driven 1 to 15 Nov 2026.
Auth0, Clerk, FusionAuth, Kinde, PropelAuth, SuperTokens and WorkOS.
With a CLI: Auth0, Clerk, PropelAuth, SuperTokens and WorkOS.
Auth0, Clerk, FusionAuth, HumanMirror, Kinde, SuperTokens, Web3Auth (MetaMask Embedded Wallets) and WorkOS.
First key made in a browser: Kinde, SuperTokens and Web3Auth (MetaMask Embedded Wallets).
Auth0, Clerk, FusionAuth, Kinde, SuperTokens and WorkOS.
Runs on its own (L4 or higher): FusionAuth and SuperTokens.
HumanMirror.
First stop: payment: Auth0, Kinde, SuperTokens and Web3Auth (MetaMask Embedded Wallets). Payment not tried: Clerk, FusionAuth and WorkOS.
FusionAuth and SuperTokens.
Not reached: PropelAuth.
FusionAuth is a login and user-management system. An agent ran the free self-hosted version fully on its own: it got an admin and an API key without any person, and ran all seven core jobs end to end. The hosted cloud sign-up, where licenses are bought, is behind a visible reCAPTCHA checkbox.
PropelAuth is a login and user-management service for software teams. An agent could read all its documentation and use its free guidance server, but could not create an account. The sign-up form asks for a visible 'I am human' tick.
The browser sign-up asked for a name, an email and a password, with no CAPTCHA and no email check. Our agent made its API key in the dashboard, did all of the core work and deleted the account in the browser. Within minutes the core's host stopped answering. The core also runs locally with no account.
One documented API call returned a development app with its secret key: no form, no email. With that key our agent did every core task through the API. The Dashboard sign-up refused both of our addresses, so nothing that needs a Clerk account was in reach: no plan to buy and no way to delete the app.
One documented call made an unclaimed test environment and returned its key. Our agent did 9 of 10 core tasks with it, and made, checked and revoked organization API keys. The Dashboard sign-up stops at a phone check, so paying and deleting the environment are out of reach.
Sign-up took an email code in the browser, with no CAPTCHA. The CLI's device login then gave our agent its token without a browser, and it made, used and revoked a scoped machine-to-machine app from the CLI. It did 9 of 10 core tasks. A visible Cloudflare check guards the Dashboard, so buying a plan and deleting the tenant need a person.
Sign-up took an email code in the browser, with no CAPTCHA and no card. The first key took the dashboard: a machine-to-machine app with 172 scope switches. After that, our agent made and revoked keys and apps through the API. It did 8 of 9 core tasks and deleted the business in the browser.
HumanMirror sells safety checks and small data tools for AI agents. An agent got a working key by itself in one request, with no email or card, and ran most of the tasks it could reach. It stopped at the paid plans, at one tool that did not repair broken JSON, and at account clean-up, where no delete route was found.
Web3Auth, now MetaMask Embedded Wallets, lets apps give their users a wallet through a login. An agent signed up with an emailed code and set up a project on its own, and made wallets and signatures through a test phone login. It stopped at a picture puzzle on email login and at a backend token check whose docs do not match the product.
Our agent drove each auth provider between 1 and 15 Nov 2026: find the docs, get in, do the core work, pay, leave. It signs every request, never solves a CAPTCHA and signs up with its own address. Our method
Level first, then the share of core work done, then minutes to get in. Levels run from L0 to L5. What the levels mean
AgentDrives Lab. “Best auth provider for AI agents: FusionAuth.” 4 Nov 2026. agentdrives.com/research/best-auth-providers-for-ai-agentsDrive data CC BY 4.0
Our agent got in on its own at 8 of 9. Clerk and WorkOS need no account at all: one documented API call returns a development app or a test environment with its key. At SuperTokens, Auth0 and Kinde our agent signed up in a browser, with no CAPTCHA, and did most of the core work after that.
Clerk and SuperTokens, tied at the top: our agent did every core task at both on its own. Pick Clerk to start before anyone has an account. Pick SuperTokens when the agent must also delete its account at the end. Auth0, WorkOS and Kinde follow, also at L4.
At some. Our agent got into 109 of 246 products we drove without a person. Where it was stopped, it was nearly always at sign-up, most often by a bot check on the form. In auth it got into 8 of 9.
In auth, 8 of 9 we drove: Auth0, Clerk, FusionAuth, HumanMirror, Kinde, SuperTokens, Web3Auth (MetaMask Embedded Wallets) and WorkOS. Across every category, 109 of 246 let our agent in on its own. Each category page lists which ones, with the wall that stopped it at the rest.
7 of 9: Auth0, Clerk, FusionAuth, HumanMirror, Kinde, PropelAuth and WorkOS. Our agent did its tasks through Auth0's local server. Clerk's and WorkOS's sign in through a consent page that needs an account, and Kinde's sign-in has no way for a new client to register.
Our agent paid at 0 of 9. Auth0, Clerk, Kinde, SuperTokens and WorkOS offer no x402, MPP or billing API. Auth0 puts a CAPTCHA before its checkout, Kinde and SuperTokens a card form, and Clerk and WorkOS sell plans only to an account.